Signs Aren’t Always the Answer: The Psychology of Handwashing
One of my former bosses loved signs. He would hang a sign for anything: ‘Don’t use this door.’ ‘Don’t block this door.’ ‘You must be ready to work at your scheduled time.’ And, of course, ‘Wash your hands.’ He wasn’t alone. Walk into almost any commercial kitchen, and you’ll find a sign over the hand sink reminding employees to wash their hands. Some are laminated, some are faded, and most have hung there so long nobody sees them anymore. And yes, they are required by the food code. But, here’s the thing: your staff already know they should wash their hands. Nobody makes it through a food safety course without hearing it. In fact, in our research, we know employees know this, but they still don’t do it.
So why doesn’t it happen more? We know it isn’t a knowledge problem. It’s a design and habit problem. That’s good news, because design is something you can change this week in each of your operations.
Most of what we do in a busy kitchen happens on autopilot. Habits form when a reliable cue, like finishing raw chicken or walking back in from the dining room, triggers the same action every time – washing your hands. If the sink isn’t where that cue happens, the habit never gets a chance to form.
People also take the path of least resistance. Every extra step, empty soap dispenser, or hand sink blocked by today’s delivery makes skipping the easier choice. Behavioral scientists call small changes to the environment “nudges”. These nudges make the right behavior easier or more automatic without forcing it.
The research on this is fascinating. In one study, researchers tracked nearly 200,000 restroom visits at a highway rest stop and found that normative cues, signs about what others were doing and the presence of more individuals in the facility, increased handwashing. In another study, they changed the environment by simply adding brightly painted paths and footprints to the sink and other social cues, and handwashing skyrocketed from 4% to 7%! No lectures required. Our kitchens aren’t schools, but the lessons hold: increase the normative expectations and change the space, and you change the habit.
…Stop asking “Why won’t they wash?” and start asking “What makes washing hard?” If the sink is out of sight, blocked, or three stations away, no sign will fix it…
The FDA Food Code requires that hand sinks be located for convenient use in prep, dispensing, and warewashing areas and kept accessible at all times. Some states get more specific; for example, requiring a hand sink within 25 feet of those areas. But “legal” and “convenient” aren’t always the same thing.
In CDC’s EHS-Net study, handwashing was more likely when a hand sink was within the worker’s line of sight and when the kitchen had more than one sink. A good rule of thumb: every station should be able to see and reach a hand sink in about 10 to 20 steps. Sinks belong at transition points, between raw-protein prep and ready-to-eat stations, near dish and waste areas, and at the kitchen entry.
Details at the sink matter, too. Put a pleasant foaming soap in a hands-free or easy-push dispenser right over the basin, with towels within arm’s reach. Bright lighting, warm water that arrives quickly, and a contrasting backsplash help the sink stand out.
Low-Cost Nudges to Try
- Make sure soap and towels are immediately available, right at the sink. If someone has to reach around equipment or step aside to grab a towel, the wash gets skipped. Keep both within easy reach of the basin.
- Hang an angled acrylic mirror above the sink. People tend to act as if they’re being observed when they see themselves.
- Make the sink stand out. A brightly colored, wipe-clean wall panel or backsplash behind the sink catches the eye from across the line. Like the painted paths in Bangladesh, it can act as a cue.
- Add a social-norm message to the mirror. It tells people that washing is what their crew does and what is expected of them.
- Mount glove boxes beside the hand sink, not at the work station. Some studies have linked glove use with less handwashing. With gloves next to the sink, it connects the two, so washing becomes the step right before gloving.
Before rolling out a change everywhere, run a simple pilot for two to four weeks. Pick two comparable stations or shifts and spend the first week just observing both. Then add one nudge, say glove boxes at the sink, to one station for two weeks, leaving the other as your comparison. Measure compliance as washes divided by handwashing opportunities (glove changes, after raw protein, after trash, coming back in the kitchen), observing three 20-minute windows per. A gain of 10 percentage points or more over the comparison station is worth keeping. Rotate observers, because people behave better when they know they’re watched, and track soap use from refill logs as a backup.
Once the change is in place, monitor a few metrics over time: your compliance rate, soap and towel use per 100 labor hours, how often daily checks find a blocked or empty sink, and any handwashing-related violations during inspections.
Telling people to wash their hands hasn’t worked for decades. Making it the easiest thing to do just might. Risk Nothing.
READ MORE POSTS
Is a Food Safety Culture on your New Year’s Resolutions List?
We hope you all had a wonderful Holiday season and are getting ready for a great new year!
Don’t Underestimate the Importance of Employee Health as we head into the Winter Months
Early this month, I ran across an article discussing an outbreak investigation in the Australian Capital Territory. The outbreak caused more than 200 people to fall ill and was one of the most widespread outbreak investigations in the history of the territory. The cause was traced back to Norovirus, a virus I am sure you have heard us opine about in this blog before.
Exclusion and Restrictions: Understanding Employee Health and the Food Code
I received a call earlier in the month from a foodservice operator who suspected that one of their employees may have fallen ill and wondered if they had to send the employee home for the day. Once I started to ask a few more questions, it became obvious that the operator wasn’t really in-tune with the food code requirements on restrictions or exclusions for employees who may not be feeling well. Given that most operations are dealing with staff shortages currently and the fact that we are about to head into the fall and winter – when we tend to see an increase in upper respiratory and other illnesses, such as the flu - it seemed like a very timely and important topic for the blog this month.
Cross Contamination and the Surfaces that go Unnoticed
In October, I ran across a new research study published in the Journal of Food Protection in early-September. The article explored cross contamination in consumer kitchens during meal preparation. One of the authors was a previous SafeBites presenter, Dr. Ellen Shumaker, at North Carolina State University. Although the setting was consumer kitchens and not the commercial kitchen many of you deal with daily, the findings were very applicable to what we often see in the foodservice setting.













