Decoding the Consumer Advisory Requirement
When designing a menu featuring items such as a medium-rare steak, eggs cooked sunny-side-up, or a tuna tartare, the culinary presentation and the item’s profit margins are often the most important considerations. However, failing to provide the consumer advisory required for these dishes can result in an automatic health code violation.
To remain fully compliant with regulatory standards, retail foodservice operations that serve raw or undercooked animal foods must properly format and display a Consumer Advisory, which is outlined in Section 3-603.11 of the 2022 FDA Food Code, Consumption of Animal Foods that are Raw, Undercooked, or Not Otherwise Processed to Eliminate Pathogens.
According to the code, if an animal food, such as beef, eggs, fish, lamb, pork, poultry, or shellfish, is served or sold raw, undercooked, or without being processed to eliminate pathogens, the foodservice operation must inform consumers of the increased health risk. To satisfy this, your menu or setup must incorporate two distinct structural components:
- The Disclosure: A written statement that clearly identifies the animal-derived foods that are, or can be ordered, raw, undercooked, or without otherwise being processed to eliminate pathogens. This must be specific and developed from your menu, for example, Caesar Salad, hamburgers, or whatever items you have on your menu that can be ordered raw, undercooked, or without food preservation.
- The Reminder: Under the FDA Food Code, consumer advisory reminders must link raw or undercooked animal foods to a footnote that warns of increased foodborne illness risks, either generally or for vulnerable populations, or alternatively states that written safety information is available upon request.
…failing to provide the required consumer advisory for raw or undercooked dishes can result in an automatic health code violation…
Operators have flexibility in how they display disclosures on their menus. Executing the consumer advisory requires a balance between regulatory compliance and guest experience. Common methods include explicitly describing the items within the menu text, such as “Oysters on the half shell (raw)”, “Caesar Salad (uncooked egg)”, or “Ribeye steak (cooked to order)” or attaching a symbol (like an asterisk) directly next to the menu item name to link it to a footnote.
If you use the asterisk method, it must point directly to a reminder footnote at the bottom of the menu. While the exact wording can vary slightly depending on state and local health department adoptions, a widely accepted standard that is pulled from the food code itself reads: “Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.” Be sure the font size of your footnote is legible. Health inspectors frequently cite menus in which the consumer advisory text is reduced to unreadable fine print at the very bottom margin.
Hard-copy menus used in the operation are not the only place guests view your offerings. If your establishment utilizes digital displays, online ordering platforms, QR code menus, or third-party delivery apps, the consumer advisory must be visible there as well. Ensure your website or ordering portal clearly displays the required disclosure and reminder text before a customer can finalize checkout.
If your concept changes its menu daily or writes specials on a chalkboard, printing new menus constantly is impractical. The Food Code allows alternative posting methods when menus are absent, such as brochures, table tents, or clearly visible notices displayed at the point of ordering.
A consumer advisory is more than just a box to check for a health inspector; it is a vital communication tool that protects both your guests, especially highly susceptible populations, and your business liability. Review your menus today to ensure your disclosures and reminders are properly paired, easy to read, and fully aligned with Section 3-603.11 Risk Nothing.
READ MORE POSTS
Food Recalls: Another Important Reason to Have a Sound Traceability Program in your Foodservice Operation
Earlier in the month, I discussed a bit about the proposed traceability rules that may be coming out soon. One result of implementing the proposed rule and improving overall food traceability in your operation is the ability of those in the food chain to quickly identify and pull product involved in a food recall.
Food Traceability in Foodservice Operations: An Essential, and Soon-to-be Required, Component of your Food Safety Plan
In June, I discussed the importance of having a solid food defense plan, and I provided you some resources for developing or strengthening your food defense plan. As I was writing those blogs, my mind kept turning toward food traceability. While they are distinctly different concepts, food traceability goes hand-in-hand with a food defense program. I would argue for your food defense plan to be effective, you must have an effective internal food traceability program, where you can trace the product back to the supplier (backward traceability), but also be able to trace the product from the supplier to the guest who was served the product (forward traceability).
Food Defense Plan Resources – at just the right price…
Earlier in the month, I discussed the importance of having a solid food defense plan in place for your foodservice operation. Even if the first version of your plan is not perfect, it is a start. Having plans down on paper will force you to think through the process and ensure the vulnerable points where opportunities exist for possible contamination within the operation are mitigated.
Don’t Turn a Blind Eye to Your Food Defense Practices
Late last week, as I mindlessly scrolled through Twitter, I ran across a Tweet suggesting the #IceCreamChallenge from summer 2019 was the real cause of the Coronavirus spread. Of course, the Tweet was made tongue in cheek, but it did cause me to reflect on that challenge, which had a short life on social media in the summer of 2019.
